Douglas Haig: Architect of Victory

architect-of-victory-douglas-haigContinuing with my personal reading challenge to read more non fiction books I have now ventured into the field of biography.   The subject of this very fine biography by Walter Reid is Douglas Haig the man who became Commander in Chief of the British Army during the First World War.  I had not particularly intended to read this or any other biography but came across it by chance while browsing, as is my want, in our local library.  Published in 2007, Reid’s book has the advantage of incorporating recent historical research into both the war and into Haig’s role during that war.  For the First World War in general and Haig in particular, the gap between academic research and popular opinion remains abysmal.  Lions led by Donkeys is still the most commonly held view of the way the war was conducted.  Brave soldiers led by blinkered, incompetent and class bound generals.  And chief donkey of all was of course Haig himself.  This was not the view at the time and only became popular from the 1960s onwards.  However this view has become more or less entrenched.  It is thus a brave man who attempts to set the record straight with a non academic biography aimed at the general public.

This is more or less what Walter Reid has done with this book.  Though the First World War does of course take up a lot of space, the book is more about Haig the person and those looking for a narrative of the War will be disappointed.  Reid does not pull any punches in his account of Haig.  This is very much a warts and all picture of the great man.  He was a driven and very ambitious person and came across to most people as cold and aloof.  However he was not blind to new developments.  Far from it, he was at the forefront of supporting and encouraging technical break throughs of all kinds.  He was also an extremely accomplished organizer and administrator.  A key requirement in the Commander in Chief of a million strong army.  The book covers all of Haig’s life, from his childhood to his death.  Though not a member of the aristocracy, Haig came from a wealthy and well connected whisky family from Fife.  One of the most fascinating aspects of the book is the extent to which Haig’s rise was facilitated by his important connections, including the Royal Family, all the way up to the King.  This was not unusual in this period, but it still surprises a bit to discover just how much power and influence the Royal Family had then.  Reid is in fact particularly good at unraveling the intricate infighting both within the higher echelons of the army and between the military and the politicians.  When we bemoan the misuse of our current lot of press barons it is timely to be reminded of the even greater power some of them had then.

I would very strongly recommend this book to anyone wanted to re-evaluate Haig himself or the First World War.  Haig’s failures and weaknesses are fully documented and analysed.  However in the end Haig emerges or should that be re-emerges as a leader whose strengths and successes were far more significant to the winning of the war.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Douglas Haig: Architect of Victory

  1. Thanks for the summary. I should probably read this book to see a different view. I generally forgive the Generals for the slaughter on 1st July1916, despite the previous failures at Ypres and Loos. However, I can’t reconcile the continuation of exactly the same tactics in the following 4 months, without finding the Generals culpable. My own site illustrates a local assault in Flers in October 1916. A predicable disaster, in which I am fortunate my grandfather was only wounded. Thanks Mr Haig…
    http://17thmanchesters.wordpress.com/about/

  2. Pingback: Reading Highlights – May 2013 | thebargellist

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s